|
|
|
Differences
between IDEA and Section 504
|
IDEA |
Section 504 |
|
Remedial:
Requires the provision of programs and services in addition to those
available to persons without disabilities (Affirmative Action) |
Requires
that current barriers to education for children with disabilities be
removed (Non-discrimination: Levels the playing field) |
|
Federal
funding is provided to support additional services to children |
Federal
funding is not provided to support efforts at removing barriers to
children’s education |
|
Applies
to educational agencies who seek to obtain funds under IDEA |
Applies
to education agencies if even a single of their programs or activities
receive financial assistance from any Federal source |
|
Protects
persons with a disability who meet certain specified disability
categories, making them eligible for services (Narrow band) |
Protects
all persons with a disability who: 1. have a physical or mental impairment
which substantially limits one or more major life activities. 2. have a
record of such and impairment; or 3. are regarded as having such an
impairment (Wider band) |
|
Defines
FAPE to include the provision of special education and related services |
Defines
FAPE to include the provision of special or regular education and related
services |
|
Focuses
on the unique educational needs of the student |
Looks
at comparing the education of students with and without disabilities |
|
There
are timelines for evaluation, and membership of the team is prescribed |
There
are no timelines for evaluation (within a reasonable period of time) and
membership of the team is not prescribed |
|
Parents
must receive written notice of actions regarding identification,
evaluation, and placement and must provide written consent prior to the
initial evaluation and placement of their child |
Written
notice is not required for identification, evaluation, and placement, and
there is no consent requirement |
*Defines a physical or mental impairment as any physiological disorder or condition, cosmetic disfigurement or anatomical loss affecting one or more of the following body systems: neurological, musculoskeletal, special sense organs, respiratory including speech organs, cardiovascular, reproductive, digestive, genito-urinary, hemic and lymphatic, skin or endocrine: or any mental or psychological disorder such as mental retardation, organic brain syndrome, emotional or mental illness and specific learning disabilities.
*A
person’s physical or mental impairment must have a substantial limitation
(permanent or temporary) on one or more major life activities.
When looking at school children the critical question is whether a
student’s impairment substantially limits the ability to learn
*An otherwise qualified individual with a disability under section 504 is one who with reasonable accommodations is able to meet all of the program’s requirements in spite of the disability.
*Schools
can adopt a set of procedures specifically for Section 504 proceedings, or they
can follow the procedural safeguards required by IDEA. Most schools have done
neither.
*Disciplinary
considerations: Must decide if suspension for more than 10 consecutive days
creates a significant change in placement, and whether the misconduct is a
manifestation of the student’s disability.